KEEP RELIGIOUS INFLUENCE OUT OF SUPERINTENDENT SEARCH

We hoped that when the initial focus group plan for the Superintendent of Schools search came out noting one group would be "faith leaders" it would be altered.

It appears not to be the case as the latest plan includes leaders of religious groups offering specific input.

From the district website:

Faith Leaders:  Tuesday, 9/9 6:00 PM.  Leaders in the numerous houses of worship throughout Maplewood and South Orange often have trusting relationships and insight into the needs and concerns of their members - families with students in our school district.  We would like their input on the strengths and challenges facing our school district and important characteristics for the next Superintendent from the perspective of community members they represent.   The Board is not seeking input of a religious nature.

This is a clear violation of the separation of church and state and a dangerous road to go down. Yes, religious leaders may be a part of the community. But to give them a separate position to advise on the hiring of a superintendent is improper. 

For that matter, one can argue that giving too many groups input is casting too wide a net for guidance on hiring a superintendent.

The Board of Education is elected by the residents to hire a superintendent as part of their job. Yes, input from residents, teachers, students and others is important. And the fact that the board has posted a plan for it and an online survey is a key element of that process.

But to give religious leaders their own seat at the table goes against every facet of public education and the clear line between religious influence and freedom of religion, and from religion.

This district has taken such a stance in previous cases that one could argue are much less important: the district policy that holiday concerts can include no religious songs. Some, including myself, might argue that is going too far. But it was the result of a lawsuit that ordered the district to do so.

When you allow religious leaders to influence any aspect of education, especially the hiring of a new superintendent, you cross the same line and in a much more serious manner. The board should reassess this granting of focus group power.

Full disclosure, I am an ordained minister and a Unitarian Universalist and a big supporter of many elements of organized religion. But the clear line that is needed between faith and public institutions supercedes any religious beliefs.

The board meets tonight to discuss the issue and opposition to their plan should be heard.