So it appears that one school's effort to raise money for a worthy cause has been caught in district bureaucracy.
Many residents offered donations to the Maplewood Middle School's recent walk-a-thon aimed at raising money for two good causes: Nothing but Nets and the U.N. Foundation Fund for AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria.
Apparently some $900 was raised so far.
But now comes word that a district policy against having students raise money through the school for charities has prompted this letter returning checks and asking people to donate through another channel.
If you do get such a letter and are asked to void a check
and send a new one to the charity directly, please do so. Do not let
these kids and their great deeds suffer because of district policy that
appears to make no sense.
We reached out to the middle school and the district for a reason for such limitations, but have received none yet.
A search of the school district policies finds there is a provision barring the use of school organizations or student groups to raise funds for entities outside of the school, apparently to:
"protect pupils from unnecessary pressures and the instructional program from
disruption"
See it below:
5830 PUPIL FUND RAISING
The Board of Education herein limits the
solicitation of funds by and from the pupils of this district in order to
protect pupils from unnecessary pressures and the instructional program from
disruption.
"Pupil fund raising" means the
solicitation and collection of money by pupils, on or off school premises, for
any purpose associated directly or indirectly with the school district or under
circumstances in which the solicitors are identified as pupils of this
district.
Permitted
Activities
Pupils may solicit and collect money on behalf
of approved school organizations.
Fundraising is allowed for the following activities:
1. Sponsored activities as
described under Policy 2430,
2. Athletic teams under Policy
#2431,
3. An entire class, or
4. A school P.T.A. or Home and
School Association.
All funds raised must be used for purposes as
described in the charter or bylaws of the fundraising entity. Fundraising by any other organization or for
any other purpose must be expressly approved by the Superintendent.
Prohibited
Activities
Unsupervised solicitation by students, whether
alone or in groups, is prohibited. In no
event shall fundraising be contingent upon a student’s performance or
outcome. The Board discourages
incentives or awards based upon the amount of funds raised by students or
groups of students.
External
Organizations
The Board recognizes that in some instances the
use of an external organization may help raise funds for school purposes. These
organizations may include, but are not limited to, publishers, wholesalers and
manufacturers selling goods or services at a discount as well as those
providing specialized services (local memberships, retail discount cards,
etc.).
Approved school organizations may engage
external entities to help raise funds for school purposes, provided the school
organization has obtained written approval of the Superintendent or his/her
designee prior to commencing fundraising activities. External organizations are expected to abide
by those activities permitted and prohibited by this policy. In addition, external organizations and their
representatives are prohibited from taking part in solicitations or other
fundraising activities.
But this would seem to be selective enforcement as numerous past examples of student-run efforts to raise funds for outside charities can be found, including a Columbia High School 2011 Haitian relief program that earned awards and the CHS Italian Cultural Club's Sicily Night, a portion of which funds:
"a contribution to a worthy charity. Past charitable recipients have
included Relay for Life of West Orange (American Cancer Society), the
National Italian American Foundation (as a donation towards one of their
scholarships for Italian Language) and the relief for the earthquake in
Abruzzo, Italy in 2008."
CHS also has a charity club.